Go back to the brief
Before comparing the houses, compare each house against what you set out to buy. If you have a written brief, compare both homes with it. If not, write down your essentials now. It is easy to forget a deal breaker when one room looks especially good.
Compare the things that cannot be changed
Location, plot, aspect, neighbours, street, flood risk, noise and the structural bones of the building are fixed. Kitchens, bathrooms, decoration and gardens are not. Weight the fixed things far more heavily than the changeable ones, and be honest about whether you will actually do the works you are imagining.
Compare the true cost
Asking price is only the start. Add purchase tax, likely renovation, running costs, council tax, any service charges and commuting costs. A cheaper house that needs a new roof and a longer commute may cost more within three years.
Compare the evidence
How does each asking price sit against comparable sold prices? How long has each been on the market? What is the seller's position in each case? A house you can buy well is different from a house you can only buy at full price in competition.
Compare the risks
List what you do not yet know about each property, and what it would cost to find out. A house with an unknown roof and an unknown lease is riskier than one where the survey and the enquiries are likely to be clean.
Then trust the feeling, but only then
Once the analysis is done, the feeling matters. You will live in the house, not the spreadsheet. Let that feeling help once you understand the costs and risks. Our property comparison tool can help you organise a first pass; a property assessment gives you a more detailed view.
